Logic, Essence, and Modality A Critical Review of Bob Hale’s Necessary Beings
نویسندگان
چکیده
Bob Hale’s distinguished record of research places him among the most important and influential contemporary analytic metaphysicians. In his deep, wide ranging, yet highly readable book Necessary Beings, Hale draws upon, but substantially integrates and extends, a good deal his past research to produce a sustained and richly textured essay on — as promised in the subtitle — ontology, modality, and the relations between them. I’ve set myself two tasks in this review: first, to provide a reasonably thorough (if not exactly comprehensive) overview of the structure and content of Hale’s book and, second, to a limited extent, to engage Hale’s book philosophically. I approach these tasks more or less sequentially: Parts I and 2 of the review are primarily expository; in Part 3 I adopt a somewhat more critical stance and raise several issues concerning one of the central elements of Hale’s account, his essentialist theory of modality.
منابع مشابه
Review of Epistemic Modality
and so I will focus on this aspect of the volume, summarizing the remaining papers in my concluding remarks. The classical approach to modals from Kratzer treats them as existential or universal quantifiers over a contextually restricted set of possible worlds. Different flavors of modality—circumstantial, deontic, epistemic, etc.—correspond to different choices of contextually provided restric...
متن کاملMuhammadien Reality and the Transcendent Theosophy
The rules of al-wahid and imkan-i ashraf are among the important rules of Islamic philosophy according to which the emanation of the intellect from the Divine Essence as the first intellect is necessary. The Prophet is the core of being, the mediator of the origination, the order of creation and the subsistence and the return of all beings. He is the same perfect man who imparted divine effu...
متن کاملThe Necessity of Metaphysics
The purpose of this thesis is to demonstrate that metaphysics is a necessary discipline – necessary in the sense that all areas of philosophy, all areas of science, and in fact any type of rational activity at all would be impossible without a metaphysical background or metaphysical presuppositions. Because of the extremely strong nature of this claim, it is not possible to put forward a very s...
متن کامل